ijaers social
facebook
twitter
Blogger
google plus

International Journal of Advanced Engineering, Management and Science

ISSN: 2454-1311 | Peer-Reviewed International Research Journal


Management Control Systems and Organizational Performance in Public and Private Higher Education Institutions: A Multiple Case Study

( Vol-12,Issue-5,September - October 2026 )

Author(s): Maria Cezil L. Molina, Jaynelle G. Domingo, Jennilyn C. Mina


Download Full Text PDF
Total View : 80
Downloads : 4
Page No: 124-135
ijaems crossref doiDOI: 10.22161/ijaems.125.8

Keywords:

management control systems, organizational performance, higher education institutions, multiple case study, public and private HEIs, Philippines

Abstract:

Philippine public and private higher education institutions (HEIs) operate under the same regulator but different governance and financing regimes, yet little is known about how their management control systems (MCS) differ and how those systems relate to performance. Guided by Management Control Theory and Performance Management Theory, this qualitative multiple case study examined MCS implementation and organizational performance in a public state college (Case A) and a private Catholic college (Case B) in the same Philippine province. Twelve purposively selected key informants, six per case, representing top administration, finance, and academic or unit leadership, were interviewed with a semi-structured guide. Data were analyzed through reflexive thematic analysis within each case and cross-case synthesis against four research propositions. Case A operated a formal, compliance-driven system of layered plans, government-regulated budgeting and audit, and documented performance commitments, but multiple control points and handoffs slowed processes. Case B operated a mission-guided, consultative, and revenue-sensitive system in which short communication lines enabled quick decisions, but informal handling, uneven documentation, and weak tracking of corrective actions limited consistency. Both cases tied budget requests to plans, fed monitoring results back into planning, and named an integrated planning, budgeting, and performance information system as the most needed improvement. The propositions on planning formality and financial revenue-sensitivity were supported, the proposition on monitoring was partly supported, and the relationship between MCS and performance was supported as perceived by informants. An integrated MCS framework of five linked elements, adaptable to public and private contexts, is proposed.

Article Info:

Received: 22 Sep 2026; Received in revised form: 18 Oct 2026; Accepted: 25 Oct 2026; Available online: 31 Oct 2026

Cite This Article:
Citations:
APA | ACM | Chicago | Harvard | IEEE | MLA | Vancouver | Bibtex
Share: